Files
breadcrumb-the-shire/agent-system/runs/SUPERGLOBAL-MIGRATION-001/review-guards.json
fs 9caa0a4f75 docs(agent): add SUPERGLOBAL-MIGRATION-001 run artifacts
Plan, execution report, guard review, acceptance review, and
finalize artifacts for the superglobal-to-abstraction migration
(87 pages migrated from $_SESSION/$_SERVER to
SessionStoreInterface/RequestRuntimeInterface).

Task: SUPERGLOBAL-MIGRATION-001

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-03-06 11:44:22 +01:00

43 lines
1.9 KiB
JSON

{
"task_id": "SUPERGLOBAL-MIGRATION-001",
"verdict": "pass",
"checked_guard_ids": [
"GR-CORE-001",
"GR-CORE-003",
"GR-CORE-005",
"GR-CORE-008",
"GR-SEC-001",
"GR-TEST-001",
"GR-TEST-002"
],
"checked_quality_gate_ids": [
"QG-001",
"QG-002",
"QG-003",
"QG-006"
],
"findings": [
{
"id": "RG-001",
"severity": "low",
"rule_ref": "GR-CORE-008",
"summary": "All 87 changed_files entries carry an identical generic summary ('Migrated page superglobal access to framework abstractions...'). Per-file specifics (which superglobals, read vs write, nested-key patterns) are lost. Reviewer can only verify correctness by reading each diff individually. Not blocking, but reduces auditability of the execution report.",
"file": "agent-system/runs/SUPERGLOBAL-MIGRATION-001/execution-report.json"
},
{
"id": "RG-002",
"severity": "low",
"rule_ref": "GR-TEST-001",
"summary": "No new integration or functional tests were added to verify behavioral equivalence of the 87 migrated pages. GR-TEST-001 technically targets lib/Service/ changes (none here), so this is not a violation. However, the migration touches security-critical flows (auth login, tenant switch, user edit) where a subtle mapping error (e.g., $session->get('user') returning different shape than $_SESSION['user']) would only surface at runtime. QG-001 passing (429 tests, 0 failures) provides reasonable confidence but does not exercise page-level rendering with real session state.",
"file": "pages/"
},
{
"id": "RG-003",
"severity": "low",
"rule_ref": "QG-006",
"summary": "QG-006 initially failed after migration (import ordering in migrated pages). Executor fixed via php-cs-fixer and re-ran successfully. Properly documented in commands array with both fail and subsequent pass. No issue — noted for completeness.",
"file": "pages/"
}
]
}